The peanut butter cookie is a wonderful double agent of the cookie world. One one side of craving, you have the need for saltiness, for crunch, for savory. On the other side, you have a craving for sweetness, sugar, morsels melting on the tip of your tongue. The peanut butter cookie plays both sides. It’s the perfect combination of cravings, all delivered in one handheld little edible package.
The above pictured – and I’m just now realizing that the picture is blurry – is a batch of peanut butter cookies made from the recipe in Alicia Simpson’s terrific Quick and Easy Vegan Comfort Food. In my experience, nearly every peanut butter cookie recipe has a secret ingredient. Alicia’s is unsweetened applesauce, and it works really well for the texture.
My minor complaint is that these cookies aren’t super peanut buttery, but it could also be the unsweetened organic peanut butter that I used in the recipe. Although it’s not high cuisine by any means, the standard Jiff or Skippy work better in peanut butter cookies, at least if you want a good heavy dose of peanutty flavor. Alicia’s are pretty healthy, all things considered (yes, even with the refined sugar).
The other problem with this cookie is strictly my own fault: NO. GRID. Why grid your peanut butter cookies? Several theories abound, most of them false. (No, grid-ing your PB cookie isn’t going to make it any better tasting, nor does it keep the cookie from spreading or being as greasy or whatever.) The only genuinely plausible reason I can come up with is that by now, the grid on the cookie universally means “This is a peanut butter cookie” thereby forewarning any possible snackers with nut allergies.
Still, it just doesn’t feel right when the cookies aren’t properly grid-ed. What do you all think?